03-24-2014, 08:56 AM
(03-23-2014 08:32 PM)MichaelAngelo Wrote: [ -> ]Each fish has it's own, personal, fun value. Some people have more fun with bass, others with steelhead, for example. Or, one can spend all day looking for a trophy muskie and catch one muskie and say that they had more fun that catching six bass had they been fishing for bass. Or, one can spend a week trying to catch a trophy muskie, not have any fun, and still prefer it to catching 42 bass.
Most fish I’ve caught were fun, in varying degrees. Those catches not fun were unintentional kills or those resulting in damage to people or things.
These days I really don’t like opening days, or crowded fishing venues, nor do I really need company.
It’s an overall quality experience that I seek, or trying new methods in old surroundings. Fish are a bonus that makes it even better.
******
(03-23-2014 08:40 PM)MuskieBait Wrote: [ -> ]Exactly my point...so simply trying to optimize CPF doesn't really work.
Some can catch bass all day and every day but will not be happy until they catch a personal best bass. They are still catching bass, and optimizing the CPF...but their utility factor is different.
Some people can do the same thing over and over again and find the same utility...while some just get bored and don't receive the same utility.
The utility factor is different for every situation...so it can't really be quantified.
How do you compare catching a 5lb Brook Trout vs. a 100lb Tarpon? How do you compare catching a record 60lb Northern Pike after a 30 year dedicated pursue vs. a guided and chartered 1000lb Black Marlin depending on the captain and mates expertise?
If CPF is the metric for measurement, then I would have had a piss poor time last weekend in Quebec. But instead, I had a good time because of the company and the surroundings. I already knew it wasn't a prime time for burbot...but I do want to fish with Eli at least once this winter since he gave me the invite.
Like Nick's signature says:
Many men go fishing all of there lives not knowing that it's not the fish they are after.
As I've said in our past conversations...nowadays, I get the most enjoyment either:
1) sharing new fishing experiences (helping people catch new species or sharing a new technique, especially with foreign visitors or new arrivals)
2) visiting new areas AND meeting new people AND catching new species of my own
3) meeting up with old friends I don't see often and having a good time
Simply catching fish just don't really do it for my anymore...unless there is good company to go along with it...
Why do you think I'm so particular with my fishing trips these days? Unless I'm maximizing my utility, I would rather save that money and time for something else that will maximize my utility. Simply getting out "as much as I can" to "maybe or maybe not get skunked" on a trip to Simcoe for "species I've already caught plenty before" in "places that I'm familiar" is very low on utility for me...even if it is close, available and potentially exciting...because I'm not satisfying either one or the other of my above criteria...
It’s called maturity and experience. It strengthens as you go forward.
Cheers,
OldTimer
It's not always just about big fish and hot bites...