Circle Hook vs J Hook

[OldTimer]

Hey,

The Circle hook design isnt really all that new, just the name is a bit more popular currently.

The geometry is similar to a offset wide gap Bait Holder, or a Kahle.

However, I do agree that in certain types of bait fishing, and with certain species the circle hook will increase hook set %.

In my fishing gut hooking happens at times with all types of hooks............ and I've seen it more often with less experienced anglers who didnt feel the fish take the bait - allowing the fish time to swallow the hook completely.

Settling on one single type of hook would be unwise for most fisherman.

I do use circle hooks,......... but when bait fishing in fresh water I more regularly use bait holders, and in the salt I choose Kahles or offset turning wide gaps for the small sizes and old school J hooks in the whopping big sizes.

Dig the many types just available from just 1 manufacturer:

http://www.eagleclaw.com/site/products/e...ssic-hooks

Cheers,

OldTimer